This thesis explores the interaction between dyslexia and giftedness in primary school students identified as twice-exceptional (2e). Gifted students with dyslexia may mask their reading and writing difficulties, and vice versa, making both identification and support challenging.
The thesis examines how giftedness can mask dyslexia in screening and school practice, and how tests, rating scales, and classroom support address this complex profile. The thesis addresses five research questions concerning (1) the ability of reading and spelling tests to identify dyslexia in gifted students, (2) how giftedness may mask decoding difficulties, (3) the predictive value of Nissen´s rating scales for giftedness, (4) what support students receive, and (5) how they describe their text-related challenges and strategies. The theoretical framework combines the Differentiating Model of Giftedness and Talent with the Simple View of Reading.
Twenty-four students, aged 10 to 16, participated in the study. All of them were identified as gifted, and many were diagnosed with dyslexia. Quantitative data from DLS and LOGOS reading and spelling tests were combined with rating scales for giftedness and qualitative interviews.
Results show that although most students perform within the normal range on reading comprehension, all display weak decoding and spelling skills, indicating stealth dyslexia. Teachers often rated students below the giftedness threshold, while significant correlations emerged between students’ and guardians’ ratings. Interviews reveal that support for gifted students with dyslexia is often inadequate; their literacy difficulties mask their strengths, resulting in a lack of support for both areas.
The findings underline the need for more nuanced identification and differentiated instruction that address both literacy challenges and giftedness. Assessment practices should consider multiple perspectives and recognise spelling as a key indicator of dyslexia, even when reading comprehension seems intact.